Harper Philanthropic

How Donors Learn from the People They Fund

How Donors Learn from the People They Fund

Early in my work with a new client, I ask a simple question. “Which parts of your giving are working?”

There is usually a pause. Sometimes a client says, “I’ve never actually thought about it that way.” These are people who can tell me in detail how their business makes money and whom among their executives they would trust with a hard decision. When the subject turns to their own giving, the answer is harder.

So I ask a second question. “Tell me about an organization you have funded that you think you should stop funding.” Most donors have one in mind, and some have been thinking about it for a while. Ending a relationship is painful, and they are not always sure how to end it well. They struggle to say when the giving stopped working or why.

I have asked these questions enough times to stop hearing the pause as a shortcoming. It usually means the donor has not been at this long enough to know the answer yet. You learn what a working grant looks like by making grants and watching what happens to them over years. Giving is a practice, and most of my clients are still early in it when we meet.

The question is also hard because grantees see the work every day and the donor sees it occasionally. They usually know which part of the plan stopped working in month four. They know what has already been tried in the field and quietly set aside. They know where reality departed from the proposal. Little of that reaches a donor’s desk on its own.

So I tell donors to get close to their grantees and to the people they serve. Being close is how you learn what you are actually funding. You see what was tried and abandoned. You may discover that the people you meant to help do not see the problem the way you do. Some of it you are told. Much of it you see for yourself. You count the people who show up. You ask the program director why attendance dropped in the spring and find out whether her team had already looked into it.

I want evidence too. I want to know how an organization measures success and what those numbers show. The figures I trust most are the ones the grantee finds genuinely useful, the ones they will use to plan their own next year. Numbers assembled for funders tend to describe what donors are thought to want. If the data does not inform the organization’s own decisions, it will not tell you much about the work either. And I try not to let a good relationship cloud what the evidence says.

A report tells me a program reached four hundred people last year. It does not tell me the team rebuilt its approach in March because the first attempt was not working.

The donor controls the funding decision, and everyone in the room knows it. A grantee describing a setback to a funder who is weighing a renewal will choose their words with care. A donor reading a polished report may reasonably take it as a complete account, when it offers one view of work that was messier than the document describing it. A report covers a year of work in six pages, and a great deal has to be left out. No one has to be doing anything wrong for useful information to get lost.

I saw that clearly with one donor, a busy executive who had deliberately stayed hands off. Her instincts were reasonable. She did not want to pressure grantees or create busywork for small teams, and she had limited time. But her distance produced the opposite of what she intended. Her grantees were left guessing about what she expected and what she would count as success. They wanted a partner and were getting benign neglect. She had no idea. So we started with her. She wrote down what she expected from each grant and what she would count as success, and sent it to them. She began asking her grantees what was worrying them, and they told her. Nobody had to file an extra report.

A donor who wants a real account of the work has to make room for it. That means being clear about what you expect. It also means not punishing a grantee for telling you something you would rather not hear.

I came to this from both sides of the table. Nine years inside an educational nonprofit, learning the work from the ground up, and then the donor side, managing a large grantmaking portfolio at an established foundation. I had written reports for funders long before I read one as a funder, so I knew how much of the uncertainty and adaptation never made it onto the page.

The foundation is where I learned that your giving is only as good as your relationships with your grantees. It is also where I saw how easily each side misreads the other. Nonprofits sometimes assume a funder will not follow the complications, so they simplify. Donors sometimes assume an organization is less sophisticated than it is, and ask their questions accordingly. Both assumptions are usually wrong, and both are easy to make from a distance.

Some organizations make the learning much easier. They show you what they are figuring out, including what has failed, and how they are changing course because of it. They let you talk to people across the organization instead of routing every question through one person. With them, you watch the work change as it happens.

Making a grant is a bet on a future nobody can predict. You decide with the information in front of you and find out later whether you were right. Experience does not make the bet safe. It makes you better at judging the people you are betting on.

A donor who has spent years close to this work starts to see patterns. You learn what a project looks like in the months before it goes off course. You see which teams adapt when circumstances change and which ones keep executing a plan that stopped fitting. You get better at knowing what to ask, how much weight to give an answer, and when a grant has run its course. That last judgment is the one I see donors put off longest.

You cannot work this out in advance. You get better at giving by giving, and the mistakes teach you the most, as long as you were close enough to see them happen. I have watched hundreds of grants, so I can often spot trouble in one a year before you would. I still cannot visit the program or sit across from its director in your place.

So when a client cannot yet say which parts of their giving are working, I know where we start. We go and talk to the people they fund.

Ask me about a client I have worked with for years and I can tell you what the difference looks like. She can name the grant that is working and say why. She can name the one that stopped working two years ago, and why she is ending it this spring.

 


Harper Philanthropic

Contact

Whether you are shaping a philanthropic strategy for the first time or considering how to deepen the impact of giving already underway, we would welcome the opportunity to talk. All enquiries are confidential.